laantungir/n_signer
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases 40 Wiki Activity
Files
b3421c3e4091d56c23189765ead74346c4e4aa1f
n_signer/plans/legacy_verb_aliases.md

5.6 KiB
Raw Blame History

Plan: Legacy Verb Aliases (Migration Path) — COMPLETED

Status: Done. All steps below have been executed. The legacy verb names are gone from the wire protocol, the implementation, the tests, the clients, and the documentation. make dev builds clean and make test passes (all 10 test binaries, 230+ assertions).

Context

n_signer is being moved to a clean, unified API (see api.md). The current implementation in src/dispatcher.c still uses the legacy unprefixed verb names. This document captures the old → new mapping so the implementation can be updated in one pass. Since this is a new project, there are no external clients to migrate — the legacy names are an internal cleanup item, not a long-term compatibility surface.

Goal

Rename the verbs in src/dispatcher.c to match api.md, remove the legacy aliases, and delete the alias-routing logic. No backward-compatibility shim is needed.

Old → New Verb Mapping

Nostr protocol verbs (add nostr_ prefix)

Legacy verb New verb
sign_event nostr_sign_event
mine_event nostr_mine_event
nip04_encrypt nostr_nip04_encrypt
nip04_decrypt nostr_nip04_decrypt
nip44_encrypt nostr_nip44_encrypt
nip44_decrypt nostr_nip44_decrypt

The role-based get_public_key (with nostr_index/role/role_path selector) becomes nostr_get_public_key. The algorithm-based get_public_key (with algorithm option) stays get_public_key.

Algorithm-based verb aliases (collapse into canonical names)

Legacy verb Canonical verb Default algorithm (when algorithm omitted)
sign_data sign (from role)
ssh_sign sign ed25519
verify_signature verify (from role)
kem_encapsulate encapsulate ml-kem-768
kem_decapsulate decapsulate ml-kem-768

After the rename, callers must always supply algorithm explicitly — the "default algorithm" fallbacks are removed. This makes the algorithm-based verbs uniform: every call specifies its algorithm.

OTP verb aliases (collapse into encrypt/decrypt)

Legacy verb Canonical verb Required option
otp_encrypt encrypt {"algorithm":"otp"}
otp_decrypt decrypt {"algorithm":"otp"}

The general encrypt/decrypt with curve:"otp" routing is replaced by algorithm:"otp".

Implementation Steps

  1. src/dispatcher.c — rename the VERB_* string constants:

    • VERB_SIGN_EVENT → "nostr_sign_event"
    • VERB_MINE_EVENT → "nostr_mine_event"
    • VERB_NIP04_ENCRYPT → "nostr_nip04_encrypt"
    • VERB_NIP04_DECRYPT → "nostr_nip04_decrypt"
    • VERB_NIP44_ENCRYPT → "nostr_nip44_encrypt"
    • VERB_NIP44_DECRYPT → "nostr_nip44_decrypt"
    • Add VERB_NOSTR_GET_PUBLIC_KEY = "nostr_get_public_key"; split the current get_public_key handler into two branches based on whether algorithm is present (algorithm-based) or nostr_index/role/role_path is present (Nostr).

  2. Remove alias routing — delete is_algorithm_verb(), canonical_alg_verb(), and the alias-fallthrough logic in dispatcher_handle_request(). The verbs sign_data, ssh_sign, verify_signature, kem_encapsulate, kem_decapsulate, otp_encrypt, otp_decrypt are no longer recognized.

  3. Remove curve:"otp" routing — the encrypt/decrypt handler no longer special-cases curve:"otp"; OTP is selected via algorithm:"otp" like every other algorithm.

  4. Update tests — tests/test_dispatcher.c, tests/test_integration.c, tests/test_algorithm_api.c, and any other test that uses the legacy verb names. Rename all call sites to the new verbs and add algorithm explicitly where it was previously defaulted.

  5. Update examples and clients:

  6. Update policy/preapprove — src/policy.c and the --preapprove CLI parsing in src/main.c should accept the new verb names. The role-based preapprove examples in api.md §6 already use the nostr_ prefix.

Verification

  • make dev && ./build/nsigner --version builds clean.
  • make test — all tests pass with the new verb names.
  • Manual smoke test over HTTP: each verb in api.md §3 responds as documented.
  • grep -rn "sign_event\|mine_event\|nip04_\|nip44_\|sign_data\|ssh_sign\|verify_signature\|kem_encapsulate\|kem_decapsulate\|otp_encrypt\|otp_decrypt" src/ tests/ client/ examples/ returns no matches (all legacy names gone).